As our previous blog posts made very clear, Things Fall Apart and The Poisonwood Bible share a lot of similarities, as well as a lot of differences. One of the most striking similarities is the fact that both novels feature a man who is revered and respected by his community but is extremely misogynistic. In Things Fall Apart, that man is Okonkwo, and in The Poisonwood Bible, that man is Nathan Price. Although they have all of the previously listed things in common, though, they are as different as the two books are from each other. Still, a similarity of sorts can be found in their deep-seated feelings of misogyny.
First and foremost, Nathan and Okonkwo are very similar. They are both prominent figureheads in their towns, and their opinions are trusted by the people in those towns, but at some point, they are both exiled. They both have a large quantity of women in their immediate family: Okonkwo with his three wives, Nathan with his four daughters. They both go into battle when the opportunity arises, and they both emerge with honor and distinction. However, when they come into contact with another race and culture, they both face extreme downfalls.
As for their differences, one can begin to find them just by looking at the similarities. They are both exiled, but Okonkwo was exiled by law, while Nathan was exiled by choice. They both have multiple women at their sides, but through their violent rages and downfalls, Okonkwo’s wives stay with him and remain loyal and loving to him, while Nathan’s daughters leave him behind and regard him with bitterness and hate. They both go to war, but Okonkwo emerges a hero, while Nathan emerges with an injury and an incurable self-loathing. Finally, the largest difference of all: Okonkwo and his people were disturbed by an incoming race and culture, while Nathan was a member of that incoming group of people.
Then, there is the source of their misogyny. Neither of them were born with such disdain for women; they can both be traced back to a specific source. For Okonkwo, it is a desperate desire to avoid being anything like his father, a lazy and artistically-minded man. For Nathan, it is an equally desperate desire to do right in the eyes of God and avoiding any sinful action. Unfortunately, both of these desires require looking down upon stereotypically feminine qualities. The laziness and musicality of Okonkwo’s father, the wastefulness and desire for material goods that Nathan gets so enraged about in his daughters: these are all seen as aspects of the woman that so many TV husbands go to bars and strip clubs to avoid. Nathan and Okonkwo did not set out to hate women; they simply want to follow their own strict moral codes. However, in doing so, they would have no trouble with joining those husbands.
So Nathan and Okonkwo do have a lot in common. They also have a lot of differences: after all, one is a racist, and one has a lot of bitterness towards white people. Differences are inevitable and easy to spot. However, things are not so black and white, literally and figuratively, in their personalities. They have both been through similar experiences, if not always on the same sides. They are both striving constantly to do what is right. And, in doing so, they both possess extreme and unhealthy levels of misogyny.
This is a really interesting and informative post. You have a clear organization and do a great job discussing the differences and similarities between Okonkwo and Nathan. Your discussion of the home lives of both men is very beneficial to your post. Also, your point about both being exiled but for different reasons and also the point stating that Okonkwo was disturbed by incoming new races and Nathan being the incoming race were both very interesting and accurate. Your discussion about the misogyny of both men is terrific and super detailed. I really enjoyed reading this, great work!
ReplyDeleteThis post is really interesting and really well-written. I like the way that you identify similarities between the two men and then differences, and then identify the causes of their sexism as shown through the things about them that are similar and different. I think that a lot of the points you makes are really important and relevant, like your analysis of Okonkwo's and Nathan's participation in wars, and I love that you connect these two men to archetypal husbands that we see in today's society. What effect do you think the specific women have on the two men? For example, Leah and Ezinma are both strong and slightly masculine daughters: do they have an effect on the way that their fathers feel about women? Overall, great job!!
ReplyDeleteThis is a really good blog post. However, I would like to point out first off that I disagree with you when you say that Nathan was respected in the same manner as Okonkwo. I think most of the people who surround Nathan think he is a loony. Your comparisons made between the two men are strong and well thought out. My favorite passage is when you discuss the root of each of the men's misogyny. I thought it was very well done. Overall nice job.
ReplyDelete